Supreme DBA All articles
Research Practice

Standing Inside the Frame: Writing a Defensible Positionality Statement for a UK DBA

Supreme DBA
Standing Inside the Frame: Writing a Defensible Positionality Statement for a UK DBA

Photo: executive researcher writing reflective research diary in university library, via kudolearning.com

UK DBA examiners rarely object to the presence of an executive in the research. They object to an executive presence that has not been accounted for. A positionality statement is therefore not a ritual confession placed at the front of a thesis. It is a methodological instrument that explains how the researcher's location shaped access, interpretation and the responses of participants. For the executive-researcher, that instrument matters because seniority is rarely neutral in the field.

Why the Question Is Methodological, Not Personal

A common misreading of reflexivity is that it invites autobiography. It does not. The purpose is to show how the researcher's position affected the production of knowledge. In a UK DBA, that means connecting who you are to what you could observe, whom you could recruit, how people spoke to you and how you made sense of the material. The examiner is not looking for a polished life story. The examiner is looking for evidence that the research design acknowledges the researcher's footprint.

Executive candidates often arrive with a strong professional identity: title, budget, reporting lines, sector reputation and a network built over years. Those assets may secure access that an outside researcher could not obtain. They may also produce guarded responses, selective disclosure or a temptation to treat organisational familiarity as analytical certainty. A defensible statement names those possibilities and explains what was done about them.

Mapping Executive Positionality

A useful statement begins with dimensions rather than adjectives. Formal authority is the first: did the researcher hold decision rights over participants, budgets or projects? Sectoral capital is the second: was the researcher known through a professional reputation that participants recognised? Organisational proximity is the third: was the employer also the field, and was the research conducted during a period of live change? Temporal position is the fourth: was the researcher inside the organisation during fieldwork, recently departed or observing from a distance?

Each dimension has methodological consequences. A finance director interviewing peers about investment decisions may receive accounts shaped by shared professional norms. A chief executive researching a public-sector change programme may find that participants read the interview as a form of performance review, even when consent is clear. A candidate researching their own employer may discover that access is easy but candour is not. The statement should identify these risks without turning them into a narrative of victimhood or virtue.

From Disclosure to Design

The stronger positionality statement moves quickly from description to action. It explains how the researcher's location influenced sampling, interview protocols, data analysis and the presentation of findings. If the researcher supervised some participants, what safeguards were used? If the researcher had prior knowledge of a decision, how was that knowledge treated in analysis? If participants might have expected the researcher to act on their concerns, how was the boundary between research and management made explicit?

This is where reflexivity becomes credible. A statement that says only that the researcher was a senior leader is thin. A statement that says seniority shaped access, that participants were recruited from outside direct reporting lines, that interviews opened with a clear statement of research independence, and that analytic memos recorded moments of familiarity and surprise is methodologically useful. It gives the examiner something to assess.

The Research Diary as Audit Trail

A positionality statement is a summary. The research diary is the audit trail behind it. The diary need not be elaborate, but it should be disciplined. After each interview or observation, the researcher can record what was expected, what was surprising, what felt too familiar, what power dynamics were present and what decisions followed. Dates, locations and contextual notes matter. So do short analytic memos that connect a felt reaction to a methodological choice.

In the thesis, diary extracts can support the methodology chapter without overwhelming it. They can show how the researcher tested an initial interpretation, revised a question or recognised that a participant was managing the researcher's seniority. In the viva, the diary is useful because it demonstrates that reflexivity was ongoing rather than retrofitted. It also protects against the charge that the positionality statement was written only after the findings were known.

Answering the Examiner's Likely Objections

Examiners may press on three points. First, is the statement too subjective? The answer is to show that subjectivity was examined and bounded, not denied. Second, is it self-indulgent? The answer is to keep the focus on methodological consequences and avoid unnecessary personal history. Third, does it breach confidentiality? The answer is to write at the level of role and relationship rather than naming individuals or disclosing sensitive organisational detail.

The executive-researcher should also avoid overcorrecting. Reflexivity does not require the candidate to claim that all findings are merely personal opinion. It requires transparency about how the research was shaped and why the resulting account remains defensible. The aim is not to neutralise seniority. The aim is to make its effects visible and manageable.

A Drafting Standard for the Statement

A strong statement can be built from six moves. Locate the researcher in relation to the field. Describe the access that position enabled or constrained. Identify the power relationships that mattered. Explain how participants may have perceived the researcher. Set out the practical safeguards used in design and analysis. Acknowledge the limits that remain.

Write in the first person where it is appropriate, and use past tense for completed actions. Keep the statement proportionate: a thesis section may run to several hundred words, while an ethics application may require something shorter and more procedural. Update the statement after fieldwork if the researcher's relationship to the field changed. Above all, treat the statement as part of the research argument, not as a decorative preface.

For candidates preparing through Supreme DBA, the test is simple. Could an examiner read the statement and understand not only who the researcher is, but how the research was protected from the unexamined exercise of executive authority? If the answer is yes, positionality has become a methodological strength rather than an objection waiting to happen.

All Articles

Related Articles

Groundwork Before Fieldwork: The Methods Case a UK DBA Panel Must Hear

Groundwork Before Fieldwork: The Methods Case a UK DBA Panel Must Hear

The Access Audit: Documenting Scholarly Reach Beyond the Campus Gate

The Access Audit: Documenting Scholarly Reach Beyond the Campus Gate

The Observed Board: Field Notes That Withstand Doctoral Scrutiny

The Observed Board: Field Notes That Withstand Doctoral Scrutiny